It is also possible for a methodology to be generic enough to apply to all design. Second, valuesensitive design enlarges the arena where values arise to include not only the work place but also education, the home, commerce, online communities, and public life. We begin by situating value sensitive design in the context of other approaches to ethics and design. Detailed methodology for the 20 quality and resource use. Values sensitive practice design studies in practice.
A survey of value sensitive design methods foundations and. Moving from value sensitive design to virtuous practice. Design for excellence or design for excellence dfx or dfx, are terms and expansions used interchangeably in the existing literature, where the x in design for x is a variable which can have one of many possible values. Abstractthis paper argues that although moral intuitions are insufficient for making judgments on new technological innovations, they maintain great utility for informing responsible innovation. Value sensitive design and information systems by batya friedman, peter h kahn, jr and alan boring. Value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and comprehensive. Although vsd incorporates views from philosophy and stakeholders involved in the process, it notably lacks. In this chapter the authors present two methodologies. In designing with an eye towards the explicitly supported values of representativeness, fairness. Value sensitive design vsd is a design methodology that begins with the premise that technologies are value laden and that human values are continually implemented both during and after the design of. Value sensitive design vsd is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and comprehensive manner. It employs an integrative and iterative tripartite methodology, consisting of. It can be a strategy against hidden protocollary power, or as social architecture, a conscious way to influence online behaviour.
I and my colleagues draw on the value sensitive design theory and methodology to proactively account for human values in the design of interactions with indicators. There is a will, not only among concerned observers but also those who play and. Thus, the theory and methods of valuesensitive design are to be used in. A qualitative study of inherent values tied to the practices of a patient call technologya preliminary investigation for the development and design of a patient call application through the value sensitive design approach.
Three types of investigation are integrated in this approach. Value sensitive design is primarily concerned with values that center on human wellbeing, human dignity, justice, welfare, and human rights. The article provides advice for vsd researchers on how to complete and enhance their. The objective here is to help designers reframe their design goal to be more reflective of human values.
Kim hartmann berggreen and jacob heiden 2017 technoanthropology, aalborg university, copenhagen. Jul 12, 2018 currently, value sensitive design vsd does not commit to a particular ethical theory. It discusses the imperatives in adopting a design philosophy that embeds values into the design of artificial agents at the early stages of ai development. After presenting the theoretical foundations of value sensitive design, which lead to a deep rethinking of technical design, friedman and. A qualitative study of inherent values tied to the. Together they could form an iterative process of identifying and interrogating values in technology design.
Drawing from value sensitive design methodology, the stakeholder criterion emphasizes the range of effects of a technology, both on those who are in direct contact with a technology direct stakeholders, and on those who might not be direct users, but whose lives are nevertheless affected by various interactions around the technology indirect stakeholders. In this article weprovide a survey of 14 value sensitive design methods. The purpose of the value sensitive design project is to allow you to explore the interactional theory, direct and indirect stakeholder analyses, value tension analyses, and value sensitive design tripartite methodology in the integrative and iterative manner in which it is intended to be employed. This design methodology identifies direct stakeholders, who interact directly with the system and indirect stakeholders, who are affected by the system. Why value sensitive design needs ethical commitments. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Value sensitive design seeks to provide theory and method to account for human values in a principled and systematic manner throughout the design process.
Pdf a survey of value sensitive design methods semantic. The reading for this section is key for understanding vsd and is titled. Chapter 4 value sensitive design and information systems batya friedman, peter h. They offer a number of different kinds of activities that a designer might use within an overall design process. Tools such as the envisioning cards reflect and synthesize a variety of wellestablished methods in value sensitive design. Oct 26, 2016 event overview the tops program and spring hosted a oneday learning event on nutritionsensitive agricultural value chains in washington, dc.
Pdf a valuesensitive design approach to intelligent. Vsd addresses design issues within the fields of information systems design and humancomputer interaction by emphasizing the ethical values of direct and indirect stakeholders. The framework for the design of care robots is distinguished from the method to proceed when using the framework. Value chain activities can produce goods or services, and can be contained within a single geographical location or spread over wider areas.
Value sensitive design is the practice of incorporating human factors such as culture, values and lifestyles into the design of technology. This approach had been on my radar for a while so when we concluded. In value sensitive design, batya friedman and david hendry describe how both moral and technical imagination can be brought to bear on the design of technology. This chapter proposed a novel design methodology called value sensitive design and its potential application to the field of artificial intelligence research and design. Value sensitive design for autonomous vehicle motion. Atomically precise manufacturing and responsible innovation.
We apply a modified value sensitive design methodology to the development of an autonomous vehicle speed control algorithm to safely navigate an occluded pedestrian crosswalk. For the definitive account of the state of the art in value sensitive design, see our new book. A proposal for a value sensitive design approach to modelling. Critiques contend that without such an explicit commitment, vsd lacks a methodology for distinguishing genuine moral values from mere stakeholderspreferences and runs the risk of attending to a set of values that is unprincipled or unbounded. The three major parts of value sensitive design are conceptual, empirical, and technical. Aug 24, 2016 a design methodology is an overarching approach to design that may include a set of philosophies, principles, processes and techniques. This paper provides a theoretical and conceptual evaluation of the merits of a potentially applicable design framework known as value sensitive design vsd for the responsible innovation of a speculative future technology called atomically precise manufacturing apm. Value sensitive design builds on an iterative methodology that integrates conceptual, empirical, and technical investigations. Valuesensitive design is primarily concerned with values that center on human. Value chain analysis has emerged since the early 1990s as a novel methodological tool for. A first analysis of the usersaward programme from a value. Practical suggestions for using value sensitive design. How to practice ethical design muzli design inspiration.
Emporia state university mls program assignment isb model presentation. Value sensitive design of interactions with urbansim indicators. In this paper we present a preliminary analysis of the values that inform the criteria and procedure making up the user certified 2002 instrument, using the value sensitive design methodology. First, designers discover the values relevant to their project, and decide which values should be integrated into the design. Nonetheless, the parts provide us with a good place to start.
Value sensitive design in design science research projects. Value sensitive design free download as powerpoint presentation. Bdcc free fulltext beneficial artificial intelligence. With the expansion of digital access points and entries to sensitive data, security becomes a primary concern for. Conceptual, empirical and technological investigations. At a recent tech solidarity nl meetup we dove into value sensitive design. A survey of value sensitive design methods begins with a summary of value sensitive design methodology and theoretical constructs. Value sensitive design vsd is an established methodology employed in accounting for human values in the design of computer systems. Designed to address the requirements of diverse user groups and multidiscip.
With value sensitive design, under development for more than two decades, friedman and hendry bring together theory, methods, and applications for a design process that engages human values at every stage. It is suggested in design of technology that human values should be used as accounts and aspiration for design 7 and to be included in the set of criteria by which the excellence of technology is judged 78. Value sensitive design vsd is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and. Value sensitive design vsd offers a methodology to make social and moral values central to the design and development of new technologies. Apr 20, 2016 value sensitive design is the practice of incorporating human factors such as culture, values and lifestyles into the design of technology. Then we describe value sensitive designs integrative tripartite methodology that involves conceptual, empirical, and technical investigations, employed iteratively. Value sensitive design vsd starting point that technologies, through their use, promote or demote a value causal relationship goal to design systems in a way that systematically incorporates societal values values tripartite methodology. Thus, the value sensitive design methodology helps to bring to the forefront values that matter not only to the direct stakeholders of a technology such as physical health, emotional wellbeing, and creativity, but to the indirect stakeholders such as privacy, informed consent, trust, and physical safety. Value sensitive design is a theory, a methodology, and an established set of methods 8. We asked 39 undergraduate students in the united states to create design charrettes of parental control. From ethics to values in the design of mobile pinc janet davis dept.
Having introduced the 14 methods, it turns to a broader discussion of value sensitive design practice, focusing on some methodological strategies and heuristics to support skillful value sensitive design practice. Summary of value sensitive design by ian mcculloh description value sensitive design is an approach to the design of information and computer technology that accounts for human values throughout the design process. The aanlysis on value sensitive design of applied technology. It employs an integrative and iterative tripartite methodology, consisting of conceptual, empirical, and technical investigations. Understanding the complexity of care in context and its. In this article we provide a survey of 14 value sensitive design methods. Although vsd incorporates views from philosophy and. Early interest in computer technology, values, and design emerged in the work norbert wiener 1954 and others. Value sensitive design principles and methods can be used to good effect for the design of groupware in an industry setting, 2 a new design method for addressing value tensions, value dams and flows, and 3 demonstration of the coevolution of technology and organizational policy. We then propose a set of empirical investigations with the different usersaward stakeholders, which should yield a deeper understanding of some of the. Value sensitive design has an interest in designing systems that support enduring human values 8. Value sensitive design is one effort to provide such a framework. The physician feedbackvaluebased modifier program also supports the affordable care acts valuebased payment modifier vm program, which will be phased in beginning in 2015.
Value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and. The purpose of this paper is to develop a critique of value sensitive design vsd and to propose an alternative approach that does not depart from a heuristic of value s, but from virtue ethics, called virtuous practice design vpd. As a methodology, value sensitive design involves three types of investigations. Second, value sensitive design enlarges the arena where values arise to include not only the work place but also education, the home, commerce, online communities, and public life.
Conceptual, empirical, and technical investigations. By taking a developmental perspective and a value sensitive design approach, we explore the possibility of designing more youthcentric online safety features. A survey of value sensitive design methods foundations. Cms will continue to refine the design, content, and underlying methodology of the physician feedback reports as it incorporates new measures and more detailed data.
Currently, value sensitive design vsd does not commit to a particular ethical theory. We argue that vsd practitioners need to complement it with an. Jan 29, 2018 this chapter proposed a novel design methodology called value sensitive design and its potential application to the field of artificial intelligence research and design. It investigates those vsd projects that employed the tripartite methodology, examining the use of vsd methodological elements, and illustrating common practices and identifying shortcomings. Using our moral and technical imaginations to create responsible innovations. The iterative methodology of value sensitive design formalizes the connection of human values to engineering specifications. Approaches for project design and implementation food security and nutrition network. Central to a value sensitive design approach are analyses of both direct and indirect stakeholders. Pdf value sensitive design and information systems alina. Value sensitive design s constellation of features.
It is not enough to stop at the point of recognizing that human principles negative and positive could be embodied in design, but to set forth particular principles as design aspirations. An introduction to value sensitive design kars alfrink. This empirical investigation shows that the different and often disparate. Further, it is argued that moral intuitions are necessary for determining stakeholder values required for the design of responsible technologies. It is associated with techniques such as privacy by design that have wide appeal to users. Mar 12, 2010 first, valuesensitive design seeks to be proactive. Pdf a valuesensitive design approach to intelligent agents. Although we might consider ourselves to be ethical people, many of us arent thinking of ethics intentionally in our work.
It is an approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values throughout the design process 5. The guide starts by telling you what qualitative methodology is and when to use it in the field understand peoples belief system, perspectives, experiences. With value sensitive design, under development for more than two decades, friedman and hendry bring together theory, methods, and applications for a design process that engages human. It investigates those vsd projects that employed the tripartite methodology, examining the use of vsd methodological elements, and. Value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and systematic manner. Value sensitive design vsd is an established methodology. In some cases, they are associated with a type of design such as architecture or graphic design.
Jan 03, 2012 the framework for the design of care robots is distinguished from the method to proceed when using the framework. Value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the designof technology that accounts for human values in a principled andsystematic manner throughout the design process. It discusses the imperatives in adopting a design philosophy that embeds values. To do this, this paper employs the value sensitive design vsd methodology as an illustrative example of how stakeholder values can be better distilled to inform responsible innovation.
Embracing the users subjective perspectives, producing mutual. The concept was developed by professor batya friedman, a software developer who observed that developers in the technology community often focused on technology without considering the implications of their. Design methods are procedures, techniques, aids, or tools for designing. The latter is referred to as the care centered value sensitive design ccvsd methodology and the former is referred to as the care centered framework. In recent years, value sensitive design has become increasingly useful and visible in the humancomputer interaction community e. We propose and describe a novel method for the design of such algorithms, which we call value sensitive algorithm design. First, value sensitive design seeks to be proactive.
Conventional procedures of design, such as drawing, can be regarded as design methods, but since the 1950s new procedures have been developed that are more usually grouped together under the name of design. A survey of value sensitive design methods request pdf. In proceedings of the 2007 international acm conference on supporting group work, group 07, pages 281 290, new york, ny, 2007. The activities that comprise a value chain can be contained within a single firm or divided among different firms. This chapter proposed a novel design methodology called valuesensitive design and its potential application to the field of artificial intelligence research and design. Value sensitive design by steve thompson description value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and comprehensive manner throughout the design process 1. Value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled and comprehensive manner throughout the design process. The value sensitive design method adopts triple comprehensive methodology. Request pdf a survey of value sensitive design methods value sensitive design is a theoretically grounded approach to the design of technology that accounts for human values in a principled.
This paper argues that the value sensitive design vsd methodology provides a principled approach to embedding common values into ai systems both early and throughout the design process. Humancomputer interaction and management information systems. This guide to using qualitative research methodology is designed to help you think about all the steps you need to take to ensure that you produce a good quality piece of work. We explicate value sensitive design by drawing on three research and design projects. Valuesensitive design vsd is a concept that advocates the consideration of human principles and standards when planning technology. This increases the chance to avoid biases in design. Value sensitive design and information systems the handbook. Participatory design pd 11, and value sensitive design vsd 7, and unstructured methods such as interviews, ethnographies, and cultural probes 8, are useful for gathering evidence of the significance to users of different personal and social implications of a design. Beneficial artificial intelligence coordination by means.
7 692 1660 288 1460 1231 1049 408 560 1046 1139 633 615 807 1281 1079 1163 1423 627 1546 177 1401 347 96 780 1058 737 634 942 309 691 895